Headgear, does it protect you from concussion?

Table of Contents

football player wearing headgear to get protection from concussion

Understanding Concussions

A concussion is a type of traumatic brain injury caused by a blow, bump, or jolt to the head or body that shakes the brain inside the skull. Although not life-threatening, concussions can have serious effects on brain function.

how a concussion affects the brain

Scientific Investigation on Headgear and Concussions

Research on the effectiveness of headgear in concussion prevention has been a prominent topic in the scientific community. A comprehensive study from the National Center for Biotechnology Information indicates that while certain types of headgear can reduce impact force, their efficacy in preventing concussions remains inconclusive.

Graph detailing the results of various studies on headgear efficacy

Analyzing Results and Conclusions

Many studies have found mixed results, with some suggesting headgear may decrease the risk of superficial injuries but not necessarily concussions. The Journal of Athletic Training highlights these conflicting findings.

Causes and Symptoms of Concussions

Concussions are commonly caused by falls, sports injuries, car accidents, and physical fights. Symptoms can range from headaches, confusion, dizziness, to loss of consciousness. These symptoms can last for several days or even longer.

Long-Term Effects of Multiple Concussions

Multiple concussions can lead to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a brain degeneration likely caused by repeated head traumas. Symptoms of CTE include memory loss, confusion, and, in severe cases, progressive dementia.

A brain scan showing the damage caused by chronic traumatic encephalopathy.

The Pivotal Role of Headgear Across Different Fields

While their styles and designs may differ, headgear serves a critical function in various domains, primarily offering protection. In the sports world, for instance, athletes in football, boxing, and hockey frequently rely on headgear to shield against injuries. [Image Placeholder]

Athletes wearing headgear in different sports

The Life-Saving Helmets in Motorcycling and Cycling

The importance of helmets when cycling or motorcycling can’t be overstated. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, helmets are about 37% effective in preventing motorcycle deaths and about 67% effective in preventing brain injuries.

2 cyclist wearing helmets

Hard Hats: The Shield of the Construction Industry

In hazardous work environments like the construction sector, hard hats are an essential safety measure. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration mandates their use to protect employees from head injuries due to falling or flying objects. [Image Placeholder]

Construction workers wearing hard hats on a job site

The Design and Function of Headgear

The design and function of headgear vary greatly across fields, but all are primarily intended to protect the user’s head. The materials used in making headgear – like ABS plastic, carbon fiber, and even metal alloys – are chosen for their strength and impact resistance. These materials are engineered to absorb or deflect the force of impacts, reducing the risk of head injuries. (source)

Design Elements and Protective Function

Design elements such as padding, shape, and construction also contribute to the protective function of headgear. Padding helps to absorb shocks, while the shape and construction of headgear distribute the impact force over a wider area. (source)

diagram of a helmet showing the different design elements and their functions.

Certifications and Standards

There are many certifications and standards for headgear across various fields. These may include standards for sports helmets like NOCSAE in the US, industrial safety helmets like ANSI, or motorcycle helmets like DOT and Snell. These certifications ensure the headgear meets certain safety requirements.(source)

Limitations and Areas for Further Research

Several limitations exist in current research, including variations in headgear types and testing methodologies. Many studies propose further investigation into the biomechanics of concussions, and how different headgear might influence these. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention provides more information on this topic.

The Controversy Around Headgear and Concussion Protection

The debate around the use of headgear in preventing concussions has gained tremendous traction over the years. Critics argue that the effectiveness of headgear is limited, pointing to studies that suggest headgear does not significantly reduce the risk of concussions. However, proponents of mandatory headgear usage cite research indicating that headgear can reduce the impact force of blows to the head, potentially mitigating the risk of brain injuries.

results of multiple studies on the effectiveness of headgear in preventing concussions

Impact of Debates on Headgear Policies and Regulations

These ongoing debates have significantly influenced policies and regulations related to headgear use. Some sports organizations, like the FIFA and USA Hockey, have made headgear mandatory, citing player safety. Conversely, other organizations believe that making headgear mandatory may give a false sense of security and increase the risk of reckless behavior.

Understanding the arguments for and against the use of headgear is crucial, and the decision to use it should be guided by personal context, sport type, and the latest scientific research.

Recommend the addition of an infographic that provides a visual representation of the different sports organizations and their stance on mandatory headgear usage.

Concussion in American Football

Whilst you might expect it the big men of football, the O-line and D-line players that crunch into each other at the scrimmage are more likely to experience concussion injuries – this is not the case.  Concussions are experienced in far higher proportions by cornerbacks, wide receivers, and linebackers.  These are the players who are most likely running at full pace, who are then colliding with other players also moving at pace.  The result?  A sudden stop, and/or violent shaking of the brain.

The big guys?  They are 1 step apart, and whilst they are hit with the force that big men hit with. the collision high speed, and fast stop.   Compare this to the impact felt by the brain of a wide receiver tearing down the field to complete a play who is met head-on by the defence with their run coming to a very fast stop.

Expert Opinions on Headgear and Concussion Prevention

As the debate continues on the effectiveness of headgear in concussion prevention, various professionals from medical, sports safety and headgear design backgrounds offer valuable insights. Studies reveal that while headgear can mitigate the impact, it cannot completely prevent concussions.

Medical professionals stress that concussions occur due to the brain moving inside the skull, something a helmet cannot prevent. However, sports safety experts argue that headgear can lessen the severity of impacts and potentially reduce the likelihood of severe brain injury.

Consensus on the Role of Headgear in Concussion Prevention

While there is no unanimous agreement, the consensus leans towards the stance that headgear, while not completely preventing concussions, plays a significant role in reducing their severity. Experts in headgear design and manufacturing are continually innovating to improve protection levels. They emphasize the importance of proper fit and material in optimizing the effectiveness of headgear.

Thus, wearing headgear is a crucial preventive measure, but it doesn’t replace the need for safe sporting practices and concussion education.

Alternatives and Complementary Measures to Headgear for Concussion Prevention

In addition to the use of headgear, there exist alternative strategies for concussion prevention. A prominent measure includes the implementation of safer rules in sports and at worksites. The CDC emphasizes that rule changes can have a significant impact on reducing the risk of concussion.

Moreover, the importance of proper technique and awareness cannot be understated. This involves being conscious of how one’s actions could lead to potential harm, and adjusting accordingly. The Mayo Clinic suggests that having a clear understanding of the game or work-related tasks can mitigate risks.

Physical conditioning and strength training also play a crucial role in concussion prevention. By improving neck strength and flexibility, individuals can better withstand impacts that could potentially cause a concussion.

Is Headgear Enough?

While headgear does provide some protection, it cannot fully prevent concussions. This is due to the nature of concussions, which are caused by the brain moving within the skull. Thus, a multi-faceted approach, combining proper techniques, physical conditioning, and safe practices, is necessary to effectively prevent concussions.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision About Headgear Use

Without question, headgear protects the skull from trauma. Headgear is thus an essential protector in sports such as cycling, ice hockey, rock climbing and in jobs such as construction where the risk of traumatic head injury is high due to accidents.

Headgear also reduces damage from repeated shocks and shaking, such as those experienced by footballers and boxers.  But if this protection was complete – well, no footballers would experience a concussion, which we know is not the case.  Headgear is simply unable to protect the brain from shaking, or sudden stop injuries as the injury to the brain can occur with no injury to the skull itself.  That there are repetitive use concussion injuries in sports such as soccer, especially in younger children makes it clear that simple protection of the skull is not enough to protect the brain.

In the end – it’s the athlete’s choice, but the choice should be informed especially in youth players.  Headgear limits the chances and impact of concussion injuries, but does not remove it.  The nature of particular positions in some sports, makes concussions a near inevitable part of those games.  Any head injury, regardless of how slight, should be documented and investigated with your primary health provider.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

football player wearing headgear to get protection from concussion

Due to popular demand, we are presently have no appointments available for new eating disorder patients. We are however, adding more staff to high demand, and more spaces will open up shortly. Please fill out the form below to register your interest.”

    Due to popular demand, we are presently have no appointments available for new eating disorder patients. We are however, adding more staff to high demand, and more spaces will open up shortly. Please fill out the form below to register your interest.

    Dr Martha Pyron
    Martha Pyron, MD
    Sports Medicine Specialist / Physician / Clinic Owner

    Dr. Pyron is board certified in both family medicine and sports medicine. She obtained her medical degree from The University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio, completed a residency program in Family Medicine at Southern Colorado Family Medicine, and pursued a fellowship in Sports Medicine at Michigan State University, Kalamazoo Center for Medical Studies. After becoming board certified in both family medicine and sports medicine, she started her career as a team physician for Penn State University. She then returned to her home state of Texas and worked as a Sports Medicine Specialist and Team Physician for the University of Texas at Austin.


    Dr Pyron is currently the founder and president of Medicine in Motion. She is an active member of the American Medical Society for Sports Medicine and the American College of Sports Medicine. She maintains a relationship with the University of Texas by teaching classes for the Athletic Training students and by providing the Medical Director role for the Exercise In Aging Research Laboratory headed by Dr. Hiro Tanaka at the University of Texas. In 2012, Dr. Pyron also became certified in Musculoskeletal Sonography allowing her to provide diagnostic and procedural ultrasound exams in her office at the time of a patient visit!


    Dr. Pyron has lived and worked in Austin since 2003 and has developed extensive connections with specialized orthopedic surgeons, chiropractors, acupuncturists, massage therapists, athletic trainers, strength trainers, and other healthcare professionals who provide excellent service. She enjoys working together as a team with a variety of healthcare professionals to provide customized and optimal care for her patients.


    Although Dr. Pyron also has training and is board certified as a family physician, she prefers to limit her practice to sports medicine. This means that she wants you to maintain your relationship with your family doctor, but see her for sports injuries, training questions, or illnesses which affect your activity level. Please let her know how she may best help you!


    In her off time, Dr. Pyron enjoys a variety of outdoor and sports activities including soccer, softball, running, biking, mountain biking, strength training, yoga, swimming, and sailing.